I work in the veterinary field and this is my expirience with the following breeds:

German Shepherds: HIGH ENERGY. Most have a high prey drive as well. They tend to be very neurotic and out of control if you don't give them a job. Unlike a lab without a job, these dogs can become aggressive without a job. If you make protecting the home their job they will accept the task to the fullest but will probably be aggressive towards friends and family if not socialized properly. These dogs are prone to bad hips and elbows as well as cancer.

St. Bernards: These dogs are rarely the lumbering nice dogs you have seen on tv. They have a few health issues, bad hips being number one. They need a firm owner who is a good leader. [Firm but fair]. One of our good clients had two of them, one of them was a great dog, goofy and mellow, the other one started out that way but then decided she liked eating small dogs and small children. I took her on a walk one time because she had eating something she shouldn't have and were inducing vomiting. Even while feeling ill she was stalking kids on the sidewalk. One of my coworkers fostered a young st bernard and he tried to bite like 4 different people, randomly. People he knew that had handled him before. I think you need to be sure you can handle a 100lb dog that will potentially try to eat someone.

Pit Bulls: Scary looking but not very good in the guarding department as they love people. They are terriers however and can have a high prey drive. If improperly socialized they can be dog aggressive, but sometimes even with socialization they can become dog aggressive.

Rottweilers: Again, a breed that needs a firm but fair hand. I would not recommend this breed for novice dog owners. They are also prone to bad hips and cancer.

Labrador Retriever/Golden Retriever: Pretty typical dogs, if you get a dog from hunting lines they tend to be hyper and more on the smaller side. "Field Type" is something you want to stay away from. The show lines tend to be bulkier more mellow dogs.

I would really think about why you're getting this dog. You might find a nice large mutt at a shelter who would look scary enough without having some of the strong behavior treats a lot of breeds have. Also you have to train a dog how to protect you, not let them be protective because it can get out of hand really easily. I really don't have a breed recommendation for you, but I think if I was getting a dog based on size I would get a Mastiff, a Leonberger, or maybe even a Great Dane [although Great Danes can be big pansies!]. Irish Wolfhounds are also really cool dogs, but can have a high prey drive.

 

Yellow-colored Labrador are more comfortable then the dark-colored and dark delicious chocolate ones. At first when pet pets they are a little super but creating sure they have a lot of work out and they are little hug glitches. This is a new reproduce for the US. It is started in Tuscany and are very excellent pets.

 

Doberman pinscher!! my Zeus is the biggest sweetheart, so loving and calm and sweet! i got him when i was moving out to live alone in my house, i got him for a companion and for protection, i even feel safe taking walks at night when i have him. hes so smart and handsome and hes my little shadow and he follows me every where, he hardly drools, short hair so very little shedding and hes great with kids and other dogs and in my case hes great with other animals, but i raised him with alot lol. hes becoming my therapy dog hes just finishing some classes im serious i love dobes they are an amazing dog, everyone who meets him falls in love. hes a handsome boy! looks scary and is very protevtive and super smart, they are one of the smartest dogs in the world, i think 3rd or 4th, but he knows when someone or something is dangerous and he also knows when ppl or things are safe

these are all pics of my doberman Zeus hes a ham lol hes my best friend and im so glad i have him in my life they really will become your shadow, very loyal and loving and proective good luck finding a best friend doggie!

 

Doberman pinscher!! my Zeus is the biggest sweetheart, so loving and calm and sweet! i got him when i was moving out to live alone in my house, i got him for a companion and for protection, i even feel safe taking walks at night when i have him.

I love the Dobermann. They are by far one of the best dogs for guarding, companionship AND their size is perfect. Large and lean. I love that you have his ears cropped. I know many people are against it.. but it's the breed's trait and if done right it doesn't hurt them one bit. Just the cups or braces they use to hold it up really gets to them, lol!

AS FOR the age in which you get a puppy. I think between 6 - 10 weeks. I got my first dog at 5 weeks, 6 days. She was a foster puppy. Her foster Mum was a Pit/Dobe mix. The father was the same in both litters, but the male got to their friend's neighboring dog, a pure bred Whippet. This is the story I got, and I can believe it because I got pictures of her mother. Nitrous was the hyper puppy of 13. She ran all over the house, and got under the baby gate and fell down the stairs. I was supposed to take her only 5 days later, but she was given to me early because of the accident (don't worry, she was fine!). My second dog I had since she was born.
When Nitrous had her puppies they were all spoken for (except two back-outs, which those puppies found amazing homes). The youngest pup to go was 6 weeks, 4 days. They insisted they had the puppy 4 days before Christmas. I made them wait until Bear (the puppies' name) was past 6 weeks to go. All other puppies except 3 went on Christmas eve (7 weeks of age). Star and Jurzey left at 8 / 9 weeks.
They've all turned out just fine. Their names were Bear, Bella, Marilyn (changed to Spirit), Star (changed to Nana), Maddy, Jurzey and finally Nioh. 6 girls and 1 boy.

And about my dogs, finally. Nitrous and all her babies have been loyal, protective dogs. They're sweet to the core. Nioh and Nitrous have become the best dogs I'll ever know.
Nitrous's only son, Bear, protected her owner from her ex, who had just come from jail and started a fight with her in front of the kids. He stood up against this man. He didn't attack or lunge, but stood his ground as I was told.
Nitrous has protected my home from a break in. Nioh and Nitrous have both stopped terrible fights from breaking out as my ex became sick and started to get physical in arguments with me.
Thing is, their breed doesn't seem to boast any of this. One's a Whippet / Shepherd Lab and the other is a Border Collie / Whippet / Shepherd Lab (and my guess is the Shepherd in there makes them protective).

(Sorry for the personal ramble. Things are 100% better. @.@)

 

yes i agree about the ear cropping and he didnt care about them being cut off just the wires that held them upright they snagged on everything! haha my next dobe that i will be gettign soon will get his ears cropped too did u like Zeus's pics? i love the ones where hes laying with me and the one with my husband

 

I can't choose, I love them all. <3
But the one on his back with your husband(?) is cute as heck. x3

 

You might look into Akitas. They are awesome, affectionate and extraordinarily loyal dogs. They bond really closely to one or two people and will protect them tirelessly. However, they do need a lot of early socializing and can be stubborn dogs. I'm not sure about their prey drive either. You should stay away from hounds and herding breeds due to a generally high prey drive. There are of course always exceptions to the rule and it might have to do with how they are raised. My Golden Retriever, a sporting

 

breed who is about 70 pounds, is bossed around by my parents 15 pound dog and is very respectful of cats because he was raised around them all. And I think that most dogs can be protective. Edgar, my golden, is goofy and beyond friendly to everyone, but he won't let anyone bug me while I sleep. It's so out of character for him, but he protects me from everyone while I sleep by growling and standing his ground (He's hasn't tried to bite anyone) But as soon as he knows I'm awake he's back to his goofy self.

 

My husband and I were just talking about this today. In 3 years my son will be off to college and hubby and I will be moving into the country, hopefully a remote area. My husband works second shift so I am home alone night through the early morning hours. We are at maximum capacity as far as furry critters go, so we decided that we are going to look into learning safe gun handling and acquiring a pistol along with the proper license. My hubby has always wanted a Shepherd but with all of the little critters, I'm not sure we'll ever be able to do it. At least with a pistol I will feel somewhat safe alone.

 

A dog can be trained to be good around small animals. The trick "leave it" is the best. My dogs know leave it like the back of their paws.

 

Irish Wolfhounds are great guardians. Very friendly dogs despite being the largest of all breeds and don't have a massive energy need. My favourite ^_^

 

Guys, look at the thread dates before bumping up dead threads. This thread is from 2009 and the OP has not been online in almost 3 years.

 

Shar Peis are great guard dogs, and are big babies if you socialize and train them right. Mine is a 70-75 pound baby. He acts every bit like one too. He adores everybody, but is a little aloof towards other dogs if there is a bigger group of them without being aggressive. Mine is comical in the fact that he whines and cries 9 times out of 10 when somebody is at the door and actually throws little tantrums (complete with spinning in circles, whining and stamping his feet!) if he feels like he is being ignored, and loves to have his butt (i.e. hindquarters) scratched (LOL)...but if he picks up on something about a person he does not like, he will block the door or stand at the window and bark and growl. The only time he has ever shown aggression is when he detects that we are somehow in potential danger (we once had a strange man wandering our neighborhood who was not from the area and acted like he was on drugs or something...wanted to shovel our driveway but kept trying to push my mom back into the house with the shovel raised up. Krueger forced himself out the front door and placed himself in between her and this weirdo, barking and snarling as a warning. When he went to turn on Krueger, he apparently "roared" as my mom described it, and he chased the guy off our property. Never saw him again ;D). Shar Peis are loyal and affectionate, but they may not be the type that will jump all over you and constantly want to lick your face. They are also very easy to train, and do not like to soil where they live, so they tend to housebreak very easily...Krueger housebroke himself when he was a puppy on the first day!

Sorry if that was long, but I absolutely adore this breed and highly recommend them.

 

American Pitbull Terrier :3

 

Pit bull. From a RELIABLE breeder. When you start inbreeding them, that's when they bece unpredictable.


Sent from my iPhone using Petguide.com Free App

 

Pit bull, for sure! If they're from a good breeder and well socialized. Honestly to me pits are only guard dogs for looks... Mine is a big stinking baby (I've had 7 pits over the years, only one had any aggression and hers was selectiveness to dogs. There were some she would want to kill, and others she'd treat like they were her own puppies.)
Right now we had Bart(formally Tank). He is such a sweetie. No aggression at all. If someone broke in he'd bring them a flashlight and show them where the goodies were. BUT he is scary looking, so people wouldn't want to break in, lol! We changed his name from Tank to Bart because it made people that much more scared of him..

Here is Barto!

He's my big boy<3


Sent from my iPhone using Petguide.com Free App

 

American Bulldogs are a very sweet, low maintenance breed. Just their looks and size will keep strangers away. I have a male who we rescued from somebody who was going to fight him. He was starved to death when we got him. He weighed 79lbs but now he is a chunky boy,we havent had him weighed in a while. he is HUGE. He is great with cats, dogs, rats, kids, and rabbits. He wouldnt hurt a fly, but when new people go over to moms they are always terrified of him. He doesnt even care about my Chihuahua trying to bully him. Here is a pic of him, ive talked to other American Bulldog owners who say theirs has the same personality as mine.

View attachment Spanky3.bmp

 

Despite the fact that this thread is 4 years old, and the OP isn't around anymore...
I have to call on this:

Yellow-colored Labrador are more comfortable then the dark-colored and dark delicious chocolate ones.

There is no difference between the colors of a lab. Be it yellow, chocolate or black, you're getting the same breed. Color doesn't make a difference in a dog's personality or breed traits.

 

Does is have to be a purebred dog? I have an awesome lab/chow/pit who's very protective and sweet. He gets two reactions from people, either they think he's adorable, or they're terrified of him. I think it's because he has light hazel eyes, and an intense stare.

Here's a random picture of him, bacause he's too cute not to share